I have killed 30+ deers by now, but apart from one antler in the beginning, the only thing dropping is leather and deer hooves. Note that I am hunting the male deer, not the doves without antlers. Maybe the patch broke the ongoing quest. I guess it is no loss as the questgiver is probably bugged as well. Has anyone been able to complete this quest? How was the droprate for you?

I confirm that I was able to get the needed antlers by hunting deer spawning very close to Valka's hut, now I do not have anywhere to turn the quest in.

Ubi should seriously reconsider the design of this quest as I can hardly imagine it being designed worse that it is currently, particularly since it is probably the first side quest you will get in the game (the item is dropped by only very specific deer spawn near Valka's hut, questgiver is bugged) and it left quite a bad impression, specially for me a as completionist to just have to ignore it.

Have fun!

I have a different issue. In my game, I messed up a bit by breaking a few oil jars. I reloaded from the previous save, but the npc dissappeared on me in all saves (even ones, where I never met the guy). Now I cannot complete the quest as even with the path cleared, no completion is granted. Unlike other mysteries, this one does not seem to reset. Please make the location reset so everyone can complete it.

Thanky,

Same problem here, just different order of the guys. I lead the blind man to the spring, but got the "you need to be anonymous" bug and upon reloading was able to complete the blind man section. With the lame guy however, I could talk to him but no prompt to carry him shows up. I guess we need to wait for ubi fix for this one.

I have a different issue. In my game, I messed up a bit by breaking a few oil jars. I reloaded from the previous save, but the npc dissappeared on me in all saves (even ones, where I never met the guy). Now I cannot complete the quest as even with the path cleared, no completion is granted. Unlike other mysteries, this one does not seem to reset. Please make the location reset so everyone can complete it.

Thanky,

I confirm that I was able to get the needed antlers by hunting deer spawning very close to Valka's hut, now I do not have anywhere to turn the quest in.

Ubi should seriously reconsider the design of this quest as I can hardly imagine it being designed worse that it is currently, particularly since it is probably the first side quest you will get in the game (the item is dropped by only very specific deer spawn near Valka's hut, questgiver is bugged) and it left quite a bad impression, specially for me a as completionist to just have to ignore it.

Have fun!

I have killed 30+ deers by now, but apart from one antler in the beginning, the only thing dropping is leather and deer hooves. Note that I am hunting the male deer, not the doves without antlers. Maybe the patch broke the ongoing quest. I guess it is no loss as the questgiver is probably bugged as well. Has anyone been able to complete this quest? How was the droprate for you?