The first time I interacted with the event in question, I chose Gil. But since Soma was all “Are U sure?”, I clicked on Bri to make extra sure, and Soma again asked “Are U sure?”, so I went back to chose Gil and she ended up killing Bri. I loaded a previous auto save, chose Gil, she killed Bri. Unfortunately all my auto saves were after I had made multiple choices.
So I warped back to my settlement, ended the game and closed it, turned off the PS4, rebooted, went back, but still the same thing. The only manual save I have b4 this event was about 8 hours previous to this happening, and I’m not about to go back that far.
So I guess Bri will just have to die, when I know she’s innocent and supposed to join me instead. Obviously this bug isn’t being widely reported b/c my guess is switching ur suspect is somehow creating the conflict and most ppl probably just figured it out and didn’t change their mind, or looked up the correct answer so didn’t even bother second guessing. I’m going to do some side quests and raiding, and hopefully this will be addressed soon considering it appears to be an important choice in the game. That and I want that Traitor dead.

The first time I interacted with the event in question, I chose Gil. But since Soma was all “Are U sure?”, I clicked on Bri to make extra sure, and Soma again asked “Are U sure?”, so I went back to chose Gil and she ended up killing Bri. I loaded a previous auto save, chose Gil, she killed Bri. Unfortunately all my auto saves were after I had made multiple choices.
So I warped back to my settlement, ended the game and closed it, turned off the PS4, rebooted, went back, but still the same thing. The only manual save I have b4 this event was about 8 hours previous to this happening, and I’m not about to go back that far.
So I guess Bri will just have to die, when I know she’s innocent and supposed to join me instead. Obviously this bug isn’t being widely reported b/c my guess is switching ur suspect is somehow creating the conflict and most ppl probably just figured it out and didn’t change their mind, or looked up the correct answer so didn’t even bother second guessing. I’m going to do some side quests and raiding, and hopefully this will be addressed soon considering it appears to be an important choice in the game. That and I want that Traitor dead.