I know that getting a patch is a big ask, but could one of the Ubi reps please talk to a coder about this? Ask them what exactly is the requirement for the Orlog trophy. What causes the game to check, and what exactly is it looking for?

Because it obviously needs more than recording all 19 victories on the map, so what else? We trophy hunters are creative, we'll figure out if there's a way to actually do that once we know more about what action to repeat.

@Ubi-TheBerry Thanks for keeping us in mind.
Is there any way you can just talk to a programmer for a few minutes? No debugging, no studying our save files, no testing.
Just ask someone to look at the code and see what it actually wants for requirements for the Orlog trophy and what causes it to re-check those. Tell us that and we can probably find a workaround.
Yeah, an automated code fix would be better, but if you could help us get a workaround instead of just asking us to try certain tasks we'll take that and see how far we can get.

@Ubi-TheBerry Thanks for keeping us in mind.
Is there any way you can just talk to a programmer for a few minutes? No debugging, no studying our save files, no testing.
Just ask someone to look at the code and see what it actually wants for requirements for the Orlog trophy and what causes it to re-check those. Tell us that and we can probably find a workaround.
Yeah, an automated code fix would be better, but if you could help us get a workaround instead of just asking us to try certain tasks we'll take that and see how far we can get.

I know that getting a patch is a big ask, but could one of the Ubi reps please talk to a coder about this? Ask them what exactly is the requirement for the Orlog trophy. What causes the game to check, and what exactly is it looking for?

Because it obviously needs more than recording all 19 victories on the map, so what else? We trophy hunters are creative, we'll figure out if there's a way to actually do that once we know more about what action to repeat.

@crb042

Hi, how you get the "Rampage" (Complete your first raid in England) Trophy?

That one unlocked as expected when the save file moved to my PS5. Sorry I can't be more help.

@Ubi-MrM I have done everything in the connectivity guide - DMZ, UPnp, Gateway - with no changes in the trophy status. My PS5 reports connection speed test of 165 Mbps down, 11 Mbps up, so my connection looks good.

If it's a clue, the PS5 homescreen says,
Continue where you left off
Current Activity: Eivor's Saga | 20%
and the details card says to "Play the Main Story". Which I had completed 100% before the save transfer.
So maybe the settlement trophy also needs other things that aren't tracking right in this save file? Maybe instead of completing any random mission, can you identify specific tasks that would move the story completion past 20%, and repeating those might fix the trophy? (Though I have no idea how story progress might relate to the Orlog trophy. Would the Orlog tutorial be part of story progress and how would I repeat that?)
Thanks!

Hello @Ubi-Borealis, I had posted in the old thread when the PS5 edition came out, then took a break (got lost in Watchdogs), came back to finally play Paris and the upcoming DLC, and was hoping the trophy situation had been fixed, I guess it hasn't. I will add my status to this post in hopes that it helps.

I completed all trophies in the base game on PS4, then converted my save to PS5. Many trophies awarded automatically on the PS5, a few that were stuck were awarded when I beat a mission, but some are still missing.

Seems I'm still missing the same 4 others are missing,
- Viking Legend (Platinum)
- Builder (Settlement level 3)
- Home Sweet Home (Settlement level 6)
- Orlog Champion (all Orlog opponents)
I have these on the PS4 trophy list, they have not unlocked on the PS5 trophy list after converting my save file.

Today, I have done the following and nothing caused those trophies to award,
- Completed a daily Bounty mission for Reda
- Completed the side quest from the base game "The Forge and the Flame"
- Completed the new quest "Strangers Bearing Gifts"
- Changed a cosmetic decoration in the settlement
- Built the Armory in the settlement
- Won a game of Orlog
I was hoping that modifying the settlement would cause it to figure out the settlement was already at level 6.

Let me know if you need other info. Thanks.

@Ubi-oof sorry for the delayed follow-up. For future reference, this resolved after I further upgraded the Mk3 weapon by completing the 8 other upgrades. That is, it didn't award when I bought the Mk3 skill or got the weapon up to Mk3, it had to entirely max out the weapon. Could be bugged, could be that whoever wrote the trophy description has the wrong requirement listed. Hope this helps someone else, just keep on upgrading!

I've upgraded two different weapons to Mk 3 and this trophy has still not awarded.
Am I missing some detail? Like is it only crafted weapons or something like that, not mentioned in the trophy description?
This is on PS5, if it matters.
Thanks.

@ubi-borealis thanks for following up on this with us!

My success so far:
I had not yet done The Baker's Plaint mission, completing that awarded Calling in a Favor; Completionist All the Way; As It Was Foretold.
I upgraded another piece of gear to max level and got Ultimate Refinement.
I did the requirement for Skadi's Hobby and that awarded, but didn't trigger any others.

I also won a game of Orlog, but it did not give me Orlog Champion.

The list of what I have on PS4 still missing on PS5,
Viking Legend
Silent Viking
Builder
Home Sweet Home
Flying Eivor
Orlog Champion

and Eivor's Saga on the hub's activity bar still says 0%, if that means anything.

Adding my details here, too. The following trophies did not automatically award when I booted up the PS5 version.
Viking Legend
Skadi's Hobby
Silent Viking
Completionist All the Way
Builder
Home Sweet Home
Ultimate Refinement
Flying Eivor
Orlog Champion
Calling in a Favor
As It Was Foretold

Additionally, the Activities bar (the thing on the PS5 hub below the "Play" button) show's a card for Eivor's Saga alongside all the unawarded trophies, and that says it's at 0%. Could be related since it's about progress, maybe that helps you tracking what's happening in the code.
Thanks