I got gold on all mastery challenges on the ps5 version.

I loaded a save on the PS4 version with 14/15 challenges complete. I earned the gold medal on the last challenge. The true master trophy unlocked but the all that glitters trophy did not unlock.

I then loaded another save from with 0/15 challenges completed. I earned gold in the first challenge but the all that glitters trophy still did not unlock.

How should I proceed to unlock this trophy?

@ubi-smash I have the same issue. And did the exact same steps.

1. Loaded a cloud saved with all 15 gold. Trophy didn't auto pop
2. Loaded save with 14/15 gold. Got gold in last one and the silver trophy popped but All that glitters didn't.
3. Loaded a save and started the quest a challenge from the gods and got gold on first challenge. Trophy didn't pop
4. Noticed that all the challenges s how gold on then even though I hadn't played a single challenge in that save.

This is very frustrating

@ubi-borealis would this suffice?
https://psnprofiles.com/trophies/11783-assassins-creed-valhalla/JabberOSX_: (https://psnprofiles.com/trophies/11783-assassins-creed-valhalla/JabberOSX_)
it shows all the trophies i have unlocked (including "A True Master") and the one missing one. i can try and post an image from my playstation APP if the above link doesnt work for you.

@ubi-keo @ubi-keo I did document that in my initial post."I have the same issue. And did the exact same steps.

1. Loaded a cloud saved with all 15 gold. Trophy didn't auto pop
2. Loaded save with 14/15 gold. Got gold in last one and the silver trophy popped but All that glitters didn't.
3. Loaded a save and started the quest a challenge from the gods and got gold on first challenge. Trophy didn't pop
4. Noticed that all the challenges s how gold on then even though I hadn't played a single challenge in that save.

I did all the challenges first on Ps4 hence the Ps4 version of the tropiies are unlocked. Saved and loaded the cloud save to ps5 to unlock those
screenshot from PS5 https://imgur.com/a/HQMbGFE

@ubi-keo yes. tried that again last night. no dice.

@ubi-borealis I have the exact same problem except I loaded a save from PC > PS4.

@ubi-keo Another update for you. I was able to unlock this trophy finally.
I had to delete all saves for the game. Quit the game and reopen. And load a old save (about half way through the main story line). And start the challenge of the gods (wasnt started in this save yet). the difference i found was that i had autosaves that were there from the Siege of Paris saves. (more on that later). And it looks like the game is loading the stats for the player form the autosaves as well. Once i deleted all saves and download an old could save i was able to start the mission and go thorugh till i went to the first trial and got gold in it. which unlocked the trophy. This condition is stupid (for a lack of better words). the trophy condition for broze should be "if goldcount()>1". at thi point it doesnt matter if you get your 1st, 5th or 10th gold it would still unlock.

How i identified this condition. I had the same issue with Pat the Cats trophy. I got the trophy on Ps4. but when i loaded the save on PS5 I couldnt unlock it. First, i didnt even get the prompt for ^Pat the cat. I tried killing them, fast travelling to Mellun and back. even meditating and traveling back and forth. Then I got an older save (having to go back to Ps4. find an older save and loading it and saving on the cloud save (this is excrucating btw, but this time i knew i would have issues and made a lot of saves.) Coming back to PS5 and loading it. This time i could travel to the town and get the prompt. But no amount of pating would unlock the trophy. I did about 3 times each. Also, i got multiple prompts to pat the cats this time. unlike before.

At this point. I did the same as i did for the bronze all that glitters trophy. using the same old save. I wiped out all the other saves. using the old half way save. i started the SOP story line and the second i hit Francia. got on a horse and rode straight to Evreux. I was able to Pat all the cats and the trophy unlocked right away.

All in all my feed back is that your trophy unlock (save tansfer) method is buggy as hell and at this point its just faster to take a midway save and run though the SOP. much faster and you enjoy the game then all the back and forth. and the second i got my last trophy I deleted the game as it sucked the joy out of playing it having to jump through hoops to get something as basic as this to work.

I am having a similar, if not identical, issue. I for reason didn’t realize that when I got on to play after downloading the Siege of Paris gate that I loaded the PS4 version of the game. I hadn’t done any mastery challenges yet so I first did that and got the “All that glitters” trophy. I finished the rest of the challenges and received the “A True Master” trophy but it’s not registering the “All that glitters” trophy. I opened up a previous save and restarted the mastery missions and got a gold trophy but that didn’t work.

Is there any way to fix this without having to delete all my saves as mentioned above?

I am having the same issue on Series X.I got gold on all challenges, got the "A true master" achievement but not "All that glitters" achievement. I do not have any old save file to go to because I already continued to Siege of Paris DLC. Hopefully this can be fixed somehow with some kind of condition check in later updates!

@ubi-wheelyduck HI, thank you for your response. I have just checked and yes it is. I just finished the Siege of Paris DLC and saved my game. 69/70 achievements are unlocked.

@jabberosx I had the same issue but managed to work around it. I uploaden all saves and profile to the cloud on PS4. Then deleten all saves on PS4 just to be sure. Then I downloaden the save where I hadn't finished a challenge gold. Loaded it up, gold and trophy. Looks like it stores the progress in your Profile or something. I don't know but hope it helpt.