I have several medallions and codex pages but when I speak to Hytham, the option to give either cannot me highlighted.

Playing on Xbox one. When i go to hand over order medallions (I have 4) or codex pages (I have 6) it won't allow me to hand over.

The option is there, but it wont allow me to choose it. I therefore just end up leaving the conversation. Any help would be appreciated

I'm also having this issue on xbox one, cannot select the options to give Hytham codex pages or medallions

Same issue on PC

@zydrate_addict having the same problem

@benjy19871987 same issue on pc also

having the same problem but also with museum dude. playing on PC have not had any other issues until now. kind of a game breaker.

I'm having this exact problem. It's odd because the only options that won't work are those two. I can still ask him about what he does and end the conversation, but when I try to give him the items it's like the game doesn't accept the prompt.

Same exact problem for me, I can ask him over and over what he does, but can't give him any of my medallions or pages. A reload didn't help.

Same problem...very frustrating

Playing AC Valhalla on a PlayStation 4.

i cannot give my Roman Artifacts, Order medallions, or codex pages to the NPC’s. I get to the dialogue options, like for example, with the Roman artifacts guy, you have (Give Roman Artifacts) (5) and I am pressing the X button, but nothing happens. I can press X until getting a blister and nothing happens. The same thing with the Order medallions and codex pages with the secret order guy.
This is frustrating because I do posses Roman artifacts, codex pages, and order medallions, but I cannot give them. I have not seen this bug mentioned anywhere else. Not sure if I’m doing something wrong, or if you need literally ALL of these items before you give them. Don’t know what’s up.

@brettrocker95 You need the amount shown in brackets before you can give them in.

While in the Assassin’s Bureau at Raventhorpe, nothing happens when I try to give Hytham Order Medallions or Codex pages. The only option on the drop down that works is the ‘I have to go.’ I have tried exiting the game and reloading.

@zydrate_addict I am having the same issue. Xbox with digital download ultimate edition.

@landmine70 Pretty sure it won't 'trigger' until you have qty. 4 of the medallions to give him simultaneously and qty. 6 of the pages. One of the other ones was like that too... Black Flag maybe... hmm.. well anywho... give it a shot once you have 4 medallions (don't forget you already gave one away before the bureau existed. Good luck because remember nothing is certain.

Having the same problem

Is your problem that they are greyed out or that they are not greyed out and clicking them doesn't work?
You need to have the amount of hand ins collected before you can hand in as indicated next to the chat options e.g. (6) - if not the chat option will be greyed out.

Coming back here to let you guys know - the bug is that the options aren't greyed out as they should be. You just don't have enough to turn in but the conversation fails to grey out. No game breaker, you just need more of them!

@meneh That was the problem for me, but the options weren't greyed out which is why I assumed it was broken, so the only bug is that!

I'm having the same issue on PC, Windows 10. I have 4 medallions in my inventory but can't give them to Hytham. I've tried multiple times Are the medallions and codex pages linked, as in, you need at least 4 medallions AND 6 pages before the options can be used? I only have 2 codex pages, so wondering if I need 4 + 6 to make it work.

Also, relevant to Hytham, I can't "mark" Order assassination targets in my menu. The PC marker is space bar but it won't activate. I get the sound effect but no marker appears in-game and the menu doesn't change to "unmark". I was doing the Lecestre chapter last night and wanted to kill the dude in the marketplace but couldn't mark his location. A quick Google search indicated where he should be but for me, he wasn't there. So, now I'm confused as to whether the Order questline needs another trigger. I've built Hytham's Bureau in my settlement and got the Leap of Faith from him.