This is currently being looked into by the game team.
To help with the investigation, would you be able to share video footage with us?

This is an absolute joke at this point - it's not even on the known bugs page. Absolute farce, it's not a hard fix. It's literally a tiny bit of coding to change. So disappointing.

Same issue in PS5. Select Glinn, any other suspect will be killed.

Having same issue, killing Lift instead of Gallin.

Game have been put a while, why is the issue not fixed, PS5 and una le to fix issue no matter what

@ubi-spud
Do u have an answer for this yet I am stuck in my game and I don't won't to have redo several hours of gameplay

i am unable to select the correct person to accuse, I’ve made my decision and no matter who I select in my choice the game tells me that I’ve selected The first option even though I have not I’ve relaunched the game multiple times and why of reinstalling the game, I’ve no idea what to do.
for the time being I’ve decided to carry on and do other bits, but please could this issue get resolved so I may carry on with my adventure

I am having the exact same issue, I am at a point where I cannot continue playing the game without choosing the wrong person as the traitor which is something that I don't want to do.

@ubi-spud I have to say that I agree with the rest of the replies. A previous save which would take me to the place where I can select the right person is not available. I am also surprised that it hasn't even being acknowledge in any official posts, this is basically a blocker in the story progress.

The first time I interacted with the event in question, I chose Gil. But since Soma was all “Are U sure?”, I clicked on Bri to make extra sure, and Soma again asked “Are U sure?”, so I went back to chose Gil and she ended up killing Bri. I loaded a previous auto save, chose Gil, she killed Bri. Unfortunately all my auto saves were after I had made multiple choices.
So I warped back to my settlement, ended the game and closed it, turned off the PS4, rebooted, went back, but still the same thing. The only manual save I have b4 this event was about 8 hours previous to this happening, and I’m not about to go back that far.
So I guess Bri will just have to die, when I know she’s innocent and supposed to join me instead. Obviously this bug isn’t being widely reported b/c my guess is switching ur suspect is somehow creating the conflict and most ppl probably just figured it out and didn’t change their mind, or looked up the correct answer so didn’t even bother second guessing. I’m going to do some side quests and raiding, and hopefully this will be addressed soon considering it appears to be an important choice in the game. That and I want that Traitor dead.

I found some guys face the same problem as me,In the character Soma want to find out the traitor,having found enough evidence,but when choose who to be killed,whoever you choose,Soma will always kill the same guy...But it's not the traitor!
Even when I reload,or restart from the beginning of the England part can't solve this!
Hope the technician can check this out...

+1 here the same - always the wrong person is executed

@mi_sinfonia

Is there any help to get that fixed?
Im also stuck in this mission... Soma always killing the wrong traitor i chose

I found some guys facing the same problem as me...
I still know whos the traitor but whoever i choose, Soma will always kill the same guy...But it's not the traitor!
Even when I reload,or restart from the beginning of the England part can't solve this!
Hope the technician can check this out...

@chemamx man Ubisoft be hatin on my girl Birna i mean why come on she is in love she should not be an option also spoilers btw so yeah

Just so everyone else knows, I created a case on the 14th about this issue (killing Birna instead of Galinn, not Lif) and ive only just received this reply from support:

""""Thank you for contacting Ubisoft Support. I would like to apologise for the time it took us to get back to you.

From your email, I understand that you experience this issue where the wrong person is executed during the Stench of Treachery mission. I am really sorry to hear of this issue.

Please be advised that we have received multiple reports from players saying that Soma kills Lif when Galinn is chosen as the traitor instead.

Bear in mind that the development team has been made aware of this issue and they are currently investigating it. Once additional information becomes available, it will be posted to the game's official forum at the link below:

https://discussions.ubisoft.com

If you're on PS4 or PC, we would appreciate if you could also forward us your save files to help with the investigation of the issue. You can find further details on this via the link below:

https://support.ubisoft.com/Faqs/000060254

We apologize for any inconvenience and thank you for your patience and understanding while we work to resolve this issue.

In the meantime, if you have any other questions, please do not hesitate to contact us again - we remain at your disposal!

Kind Regards,
Ubi-KongCooler
Ubisoft Support""""

But along with everyone else im sure we agree that you've known about this issue for nearly 3 weeks now, which you've known about as support has been replying on this thread and it's disgusting that you've only just let the development team know about it. You released a patch several days ago which could have easily included a fix to this, but now we're all stuck waiting potentially another 2 and a half/3 weeks for you to fix a very small bug that hiders a players ability to advance in the story very early on in the game?! Frankly it's astonishing how bad this has been.

Not to mention the fact that in my case I state that Birna is the one that's killed and yet in the reply you only state that players have faced the problem that Lif is killed instead. I've bought the assassins creed games ever since the first one came out and ive always been a big fan of ubisoft as they always create amazing games, and Valhalla is an amazing game, but the service youre giving rn in regards to this issue is abysmal. I hope we don't have to wait another couple of weeks for this to be resolved.

@bentellier same here. Not fixed in new patch. Just playing side quests until they fix this...